Home
Cricket
Asia Cup 2025: Did India make the right call with Harshit Rana over Prasidh Krishna & Harshal Patel?

Asia Cup 2025: Did India make the right call with Harshit Rana over Prasidh Krishna & Harshal Patel?

Credit: Alamy
Harshit Rana was reportedly selected for the Asia Cup 2025 ahead of Prasidh Krishna for his ability to hit sixes

India’s squad for Asia Cup 2025 had more than a few surprises. Chief selector Ajit Agarkar unveiled the 15-man squad alongside captain Suryakumar Yadav on Tuesday. One of the more contentious decisions was the inclusion of Harshit Rana for the tournament. The KKR pacer’s inclusion came ahead of the likes of Prasidh Krishna and Harshal Patel.

The Harshit Rana debate – Did India make the correct choice?

Harshit Rana was fast tracked to the Indian set up following a breakout campaign in IPL 2024. He played in the Border Gavaskar Trophy in Australia, and made his debuts in both ODI and T20I. Rana is highly rated by coach Gautam Gambhir, who worked with him during their days in KKR.

The 23-year-old has the ability to crank up the pace, bowling in excess of 140 kmph. He is also a handy option with bat in hand, though Rana is yet to fill up on that promise. Harshit however is more than capable to hold his bat at No.8, an option India lack in the squad. It is on that ability that Harshit leapfrogged competition, as per ESPNCricinfo.

But could India have looked at another way?

Harshit Rana had a lacklustre IPL 2025 as Kolkata Knight Riders failed terribly in their title defence. Prasidh Krishna was star of the tournament, winning the purple cap for his 25 wickets. The Gujarat Titans bowled largely in the middle overs, choking up the runs and running through batting orders. His economy of under 8.5 is almost 2 runs less than what Harshit conceded last season. Krishna toured with the Indian team in England and returned with 14 wickets in 3 Test matches.

Player MatchesWicketsBBIAverageEconomyStrike rate
Harshal Patel13164/2826.879.816.4
Harshit Rana13153/2529.8610.1817.6
Prasidh Krishna15254/4119.528.2714.1
Indian pacers at IPL 2025

A case for Harshal Patel

India’s slower ball specialist. It was only a couple of years ago that Harshal Patel was India’s premier T20I bowler. He has since fallen down the pecking order, but his skills remain at the highest level. With the Asia Cup 205 set to be played in slow and turning surfaces in the UAE, Patel’s ability to roll his fingers over the ball would have been a valuable asset. The 34-year-old picked up 16 wickets in 13 games in IPL 2025 and was one of the few bright spots in Sunrisers campaign.

Ajit Agarkar has put trust in Gautam Gambhir’s judgement and Harshit Rana’s potential ability to hit sixes. Rana picked up a 3-fer on his T20I debut, his only game in format for India till date. Captain Suryakumar Yadav would hope Harshit can repay the faith and deliver in the Asia Cup 2025

Follow
Share

Editor's Pick

How Virat Kohli's 100 in Ranchi resulted in tickets for IND vs SA 3rd ODI getting sold out instantly Cricket How Virat Kohli's 100 in Ranchi resulted in tickets for IND vs SA 3rd ODI getting sold out instantly

Top Stories

Share article
Follow us on social media
Tell us why didn’t you like our article so that we can improve on?
Choose ranking:
ICC Test Ranking
ICC ODI Ranking
ICC T20I Ranking